EMPERIOStrategy & Research Lab
Reading room

When a larger project earns less on the next rupee

Fictional teaching story

A fictional motor maker has enough budget for an equipment upgrade or a dealer expansion. The equipment proposal shows higher profit. The dealer proposal uses less upfront capital but ties up cash in receivables. Neither presentation starts from the same question about what the company must commit.

What the analyst checked

Compare incremental cash flows, including timing, working capital and the cost of delivering each option. A project that looks strong on average can need more capital than the business can release. Separate any benefit from a later expansion until the first stage has demonstrated it.

The next decision

Show both cash requirements and expected value over a common period. Identify a smaller commitment that would test the largest uncertainty. Assign a date to revisit the allocation with that evidence.

Work the related case · Read the framework